|
|
|
No unified Foundations Code
The law of foundations is not a separate, unified legal field.
There is no "foundations code" or similar regulation; instead,
the regulations that govern foundations are distributed among
various state and federal laws. Thus, it should come as no
surprise that there are a number of different types of foundations.
We will be glad to help you find the type of foundation that
is appropriate for you and to tailor it to your specific needs.
Charitable Foundation - Family Foundation - Business Foundation
The most frequently-encountered form of a foundation is the
charitable foundation. These generally pursue community-welfare
goals. For many years, such foundations have enjoyed tax advantages
of various different kinds. The founder determines the specific
charitable goals that the foundation is to pursue. Once the
goals have been established, the foundation is required to
pursue them even after the founder's death.
The idea of placing one's wealth, or a part of it, at society's
service resonates with more and more people every day. Often,
the founder is motivated to give something back to society,
after profiting from it for decades, for instance as a successful
businessperson. Many businesspersons are able, by founding
a charitable foundation, to make a successful transition into
retirement. During the founder's business career, the company
profited from his expertise and experience; now, in retirement,
the foundation benefits from it. The maximization of personal
and company profits is no longer the primary goal. Rather,
founder's current activity is oriented to the maximization
of benefit to the community, and the personal satisfaction
gained from good works. Frequently, the recognition the founder
(rightly) enjoys for his good works is also an important motivation.
A minority of German foundations advance not community, but
private-welfare goals. A sub-class of private foundations
is the family foundation, which is essentially designed to
serve the interests of one or more families. Further, various
mixed forms are provided for by the law of foundations. Thus,
even for a charitable foundation, the purpose of providing
for family members can also be taken into account. Provided
legal requirements are met, this can be done without endangering
the foundation's favorable tax treatment. Business foundations
are also permitted. These involve foundations that are organized
to conduct the business of a company or which possess shares
of a company. Whether they are charitable or private foundations
varies from case to case.
The tax law and foundations law aspects of non-charitable
foundations are many and complex. The law of foundations cannot
be adequately captured by generalities. In each case, it is
necessary to determine which form is most advantageous to
the founder, given his or her particular life situation.
Independent Foundation - Trust Foundation
Unlike an independent foundation, which is a legal person
itself subject to rights and duties, the trust foundation
is not an independent legal entity. A trust foundation is
created when the founder's assets are conveyed to a trustee
or an existing foundation, which then invest them and use
them for a purpose to be determined by the founder. A trust
foundation, unlike an independent foundation, can be founded
with a very small amount of capital. Further, it is not subject
to government oversight. Of course, even for independent foundations,
there is no set minimum contribution that the founder must
deposit at the beginning. However, in most cases, it is generally
only sensible to consider creating a foundation with assets
of at least € 100,000. Another possibility is to make a small
initial deposit to the foundation while the founder is alive,
and then convey the larger portion of the assets at the time
of death.
However, there is an exception to every rule: The so-called
"community foundation" that has been well-established in the
USA since long and that has become very popular in recent
years in Germany as well can generally be founded with a smaller
initial capital deposit. In contrast to an ordinary independent
foundation, a community foundation is usually created not
just by one or a few initial founders, but - as the name implies
- from a larger number of citizens.
The creation of a trust foundation is usually faster and easier
than an independent foundation. However, when large asset
amounts are involved, an independent foundation may make more
sense. In the case of trust foundations, it's necessary to
carefully evaluate the interests of the trustee: Is it possible
that he specializes exclusively in the administration of trust
foundations, and is therefore incorrectly advising against
the establishment of an independent foundation? Is the administrative
cost structure transparent? Can the trust foundation realize
all of the founder's goals, or will the trustee have to amend
the charter or seek the assistance of another trustee?
Revenue-Generating Foundation - Principal-Depleting Foundation
A foundation is generally intended to exist forever. There
are foundations that are hundreds of years old. The goals
of a typical foundation are usually realized through revenue
generated by the foundation's principal. Lately, however,
more and more state foundations laws have opened up the possibility
of principal-depleting foundations, that is, foundations that
do not rely solely on their revenues, but also use up their
principal, so that after a certain point of time, the foundation
will cease to exist when its assets are fully used. The decision
whether a principal-depleting foundation is the right vehicle
for the founder's goals, and whether it is permitted by local
state law, is a matter for case-by-case analysis.
German Foundation - Foundation in a Foreign Country
Unless a foundation is being considered for illegal purposes,
a German citizen who wishes to establish a foundation will
generally prefer to do so under German law. However, the establishment
of a foreign foundation can also be appropriate - and legal
- in certain cases. Foundations created according to Swiss
or Austrian law, or the law of Liechtenstein, would be the
most common options here. The decision whether to go beyond
Germany's borders and, if so, which country to choose, requires
a careful weighing of all benefits and disadvantages. In particular,
tax consequences must be carefully analyzed when considering
a foreign foundation.
Alternatives to Foundations
Not all foundations are the same. In addition to the legal
form of an ordinary foundation, there are other forms which
can operate in the form of a German GmbH (limited liability
company foundation, or GmbH foundation) or in the form of
a membership group (group foundation, or association foundation).
One advantage of such legal entities, of which there are many
prominent examples, is, among other things, the lack of regulation
by government agencies. Neither GmbH foundations nor group
foundations are subject to official regulation by relevant
charity-oversight agencies.
|